I've had bad experiences with insurance companies in the past, so I always like to stick to one I've heard of, and preferably that I know for certain will cough up if I need them. So what I do for car insurance is find the best quotes, then take a note of them and go back to my broker and let them know. Usually they've matched them or pretty close. Worth a try anyway.
It's worth remembering that insurances companies are there to make money for the company, not to help you out. So while we all need to insure stuff like house, car, and medical expences if going abroad, it might be better not to bother for other things. For instance, for pet insurance I 'self-insure', ie put some money away to cover emergencies. I had a bad experience with a pet insurance company in the past; they changed the rules at the end of the year so as not to cover longterm conditions any more, and I had a chronically sick cat. I took it to the insurance ombudsman, who said "sorry, we sympathise, but it's legal"!
So work out the figures. Even in a worst case scenario you may be better off doing it yourself. For instance, my cat was recently very ill, and cost me £1,400. BUT...with a multi-cat household, I'd have paid out about that much over two years if I'd insured them all, and my cats had been healthy for longer than that. So actually I was better off.


